What are you working on?

Find a calculator, explore a formula, or learn the method.

THE ENGINEERING REFERENCE / GUIDE

Ergun Equation Worked Example: Pressure Drop Through a Packed Bed

Short Answer

The Ergun equation gives the pressure drop through a packed bed as the sum of a viscous term (Kozeny–Carman) and an inertial term (Burke–Plummer), both scaled by 1/ε³. In a worked example — water at 2 kg/s flowing through a 1 m duct packed with nine million small cylinders — the inputs (u0 = 0.1 m/s, Dp = 1.2 mm, ε = 0.293) yield a total gradient of about 6.2×10⁵ Pa/m, so ΔP ≈ 6.2×10⁵ Pa.

A fluid pushed through a vessel filled with solid particles — a configuration known as a packed bed — loses pressure because it must weave through the narrow, interconnected channels between the grains. The Ergun equation is the standard empirical correlation for estimating that pressure drop over a wide range of flow rates. This article explains what each term means, sets out a step-by-step procedure, and then works through a complete numerical example in the style of a chemical engineering course exercise: water flowing at 2 kg/s through a duct packed with nine million small cylinders [1].

What the Ergun Equation Is

The equation was published by Sabri Ergun in 1952 and remains the reference correlation for pressure losses through packed beds. It deliberately merges two asymptotic behaviours: the Kozeny–Carman equation (developed from Kozeny’s 1927 work and refined by Carman in 1937), which captures viscous losses at low flow rates, and the Burke–Plummer equation (1928), which captures inertial losses at high flow rates. The Ergun equation is simply the sum of the two contributions [3]:

ΔP = 150·μ·(1 − ε)²·u0·L / (ε³·Dp²) + 1.75·ρ·(1 − ε)·u0²·L / (ε³·Dp)

Each symbol carries ordinary SI units, listed below. Two variables deserve special attention because they are easy to misjudge. First, u0 is the superficial velocity: the volumetric flow rate divided by the entire (empty) cross-sectional area of the bed — the velocity the fluid would have if the packing were absent. Second, Dp is the effective particle diameter. For spheres it is simply the sphere diameter; for other shapes it is the diameter of an equivalent sphere with the same external surface area per unit volume, sometimes called the spherical-equivalent diameter [2].

SymbolMeaningSI unit
ΔPPressure drop across the bedPa
LBed length in the flow directionm
εVoid fraction (bed porosity)dimensionless
DpEffective particle diameterm
u0Superficial velocitym/s
ρFluid densitykg/m³
μDynamic viscosityPa·s

Two structural features explain most of the equation’s behaviour. Both terms are divided by ε³, the cube of the void fraction (the fraction of bed volume not occupied by solids), so modest changes in porosity have a large effect on the result. And the two terms respond differently to velocity: the first grows in proportion to u0 (viscous drag) and dominates at low Reynolds numbers, while the second grows with u0² (inertial losses) and dominates at high flow rates [2][3].

Applying the Ergun Equation Step by Step

The following procedure follows a standard course example for a horizontal packed duct [1] and mirrors the approach used in column design exercises with spherical packing [4].

  1. Superficial velocity. Convert the duty to volumetric flow (Q = ṁ/ρ for a liquid) and divide by the full cross-sectional area to obtain u0.
  2. Particle characterisation. For spheres, take Dp as the sphere diameter. For other shapes, compute the specific surface av (external surface area per unit particle volume) and use the effective diameter Dp = 6/av, the approach used in the worked example below [1].
  3. Void fraction. Obtain ε from ε = (bed volume − volume of solids) / bed volume [1].
  4. Flow regime. Compute the particle Reynolds number Re = ρ·u0·Dp/μ to anticipate which term will dominate, although the full equation handles both regimes without switching.
  5. Evaluation. Work out the two terms, add them, and multiply by the bed length L. Check units and convert the result to kPa or bar if convenient.

Worked Example: Water Through a Duct Packed with Cylinders

Problem. Water (ρ = 1000 kg/m³, μ = 1×10⁻³ kg/(m·s), equivalently Pa·s) flows at a mass flow rate of 2 kg/s through a horizontal duct of rectangular cross section 0.1 m × 0.2 m and length 1 m. The duct is packed with 9,000,000 small cylinders, each 1 mm in diameter and 2 mm long. Calculate the pressure drop across the duct [1]. Because the duct is horizontal, the measured difference is the frictional loss; a vertical bed would also carry a static-head contribution.

Step 1 — Superficial velocity

The volumetric flow rate is Q = ṁ/ρ = 2/1000 = 0.0020 m³/s. The duct cross-section is A = 0.1 × 0.2 = 0.020 m², so the superficial velocity is u0 = Q/A = 0.1 m/s [1].

Step 2 — Effective particle diameter

Each cylinder has volume V = (π/4)(0.001)²(0.002) ≈ 1.57×10⁻⁹ m³ and external surface area A = π(0.001)(0.002) + 2(π/4)(0.001)² ≈ 7.85×10⁻⁶ m² (curved wall plus two flat ends). The specific surface is therefore av = A/V = 5000 m²/m³, giving the effective diameter Dp = 6/av = 6/5000 = 1.2×10⁻³ m [1].

Step 3 — Void fraction

The duct volume is 0.1 × 0.2 × 1 = 0.020 m³. The cylinders occupy 9,000,000 × 1.57×10⁻⁹ ≈ 0.0141 m³, so ε = (0.020 − 0.0141)/0.020 ≈ 0.293 [1]. This is a tightly packed bed, and because both Ergun terms scale with 1/ε³, this low porosity substantially inflates the pressure drop.

Step 4 — Reynolds number

Re = ρ·u0·Dp/μ = (1000)(0.1)(0.0012)/(0.001) = 120. This transitional value means neither purely viscous nor purely inertial behaviour applies, so both terms must be retained.

Step 5 — Evaluate the two terms

ContributionSubstitutionResult
Viscous (Kozeny–Carman)150(0.001)(0.707)²(0.1) / (0.293³ × (0.0012)²)≈ 2.1×10⁵ Pa/m
Inertial (Burke–Plummer)1.75(1000)(0.707)(0.1)² / (0.293³ × 0.0012)≈ 4.1×10⁵ Pa/m
Total gradientsum of both terms≈ 6.2×10⁵ Pa/m

Multiplying by the bed length L = 1 m gives ΔP ≈ 6.2×10⁵ Pa, roughly 620 kPa or about 6 bar (computed here from the source inputs [1] and the standard equation [2]). The same total follows from an equivalent Reynolds-number rearrangement used in course materials, ΔP = (ρ·u0²·L/Dp) · (1 − ε)/ε³ · (150(1 − ε)/Re + 1.75), which with Re = 120 again gives about 6.2×10⁵ Pa.

Reading the result

Three observations make the numbers meaningful. First, the inertial term (≈ 4.1×10⁵ Pa/m) is about twice the viscous term (≈ 2.1×10⁵ Pa/m): roughly two-thirds of the loss comes from inertia, so a Kozeny–Carman-only calculation would understate the drop by about that fraction. Second, the actual (interstitial) velocity inside the voids is higher than the superficial figure — approximately u0/ε ≈ 0.1/0.293 ≈ 0.34 m/s — which is why the losses are severe despite the modest superficial velocity. Third, because both terms scale with 1/ε³, the answer is acutely sensitive to porosity; even a small change in ε would move the result by tens of percent.

Assumptions and Limitations

The Ergun equation is an empirical correlation developed for randomly packed beds, classically of roughly spherical particles [2]. It serves well for routine engineering estimates provided its inputs are accurate, but several conditions deserve care:

  • Packing structure. Wall effects, channeling, fines migration, and ordered packing geometries can make the true ε and effective diameter differ from nominal values; the ε³ sensitivity magnifies such errors.
  • Shape range. For non-spherical packing the correlation is applied through the spherical-equivalent diameter [2]; extremely elongated or irregular shapes and very low porosities push beyond the correlation’s tested range.
  • Flow extremes. At very low Reynolds numbers the viscous term alone (the Carman–Kozeny relation) is sufficient [2][3]; at very high velocities packed-bed correlations lose accuracy as conditions approach fluidization.
  • Compressible fluids. The example uses a liquid, whose density is effectively constant; for gases across a large pressure ratio, the expanding gas changes velocity and density along the bed, and the calculation must account for that variation.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

  • Using the interstitial (actual) velocity instead of the superficial velocity — the correlation is defined in terms of u0.
  • Feeding in an ineffective particle diameter, for example the cylinder length rather than Dp = 6/av for a non-spherical particle [1][2].
  • Miscomputing ε, for instance from surface area instead of volume, or forgetting it is expressed per unit bed volume [1].
  • Dropping the (1 − ε) factors or the ε³ denominator: the viscous term carries (1 − ε)² and the inertial term carries (1 − ε) once.
  • Unit slips, such as leaving diameters in millimetres or writing viscosity in centipoise without converting (1 cP = 1×10⁻³ Pa·s).

Practical Takeaways

The Ergun equation turns four inputs — superficial velocity, void fraction, effective particle diameter, and fluid properties — into a pressure-drop estimate that spans laminar to inertial flow in a single expression. The worked example shows the full workflow and the key pitfall: in the transitional regime both terms matter, and porosity errors are amplified by the ε³ factor. When a design is marginal, recompute the drop across the plausible range of ε rather than for a single optimistic value, and remember that the result scales linearly with bed length, so the per-metre gradient (≈ 6.2×10⁵ Pa/m here) is the quantity to compare across layouts.

FAQ

What is the difference between superficial velocity and the actual velocity inside a packed bed?

Superficial velocity u0 is the volumetric flow rate divided by the entire bed cross-section, as if the packing were absent. The actual (interstitial) velocity is higher — approximately u0/ε — because the fluid travels only through the void spaces. The Ergun equation is defined in terms of the superficial velocity.

Can I use only one of the two Ergun terms?

At sufficiently low flow rates the viscous (Kozeny–Carman) term dominates and the inertial term can be neglected; at high flow rates the reverse holds. In the worked example (Re ≈ 120) both terms contribute, with inertia carrying about two-thirds of the loss, so dropping either term would substantially understate the pressure drop.

What particle diameter should I use for non-spherical packing?

Use the effective (spherical-equivalent) diameter Dp = 6/av, where av is the external surface area per unit particle volume. In the worked example, the 1 mm × 2 mm cylinders give av = 5000 m²/m³ and therefore Dp = 1.2×10⁻³ m.

How do I check an Ergun equation calculation?

Confirm ε lies between 0 and 1 and is plausible for the packing, confirm all lengths are in metres and viscosity in Pa·s, confirm the velocity used is superficial, and compare the sizes of the viscous and inertial terms to sense-check the flow regime against the Reynolds number.

References

  1. CHE 204 — Examples: Flow through Packed Beds (worked example: water at 2 kg/s through a duct packed with 9,000,000 cylinders), King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals. https://faculty.kfupm.edu.sa/CHE/usamah/CHE204/CHE204-HD17-Examples-FlowthroughPackedBeds.pdf
  2. Neutrium. 'Pressure Drop Through a Packed Bed.' https://neutrium.net/articles/fluid-flow/pressure-drop-through-a-packed-bed/
  3. ScienceDirect Topics. 'Ergun Equation.' https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/ergun-equation
  4. Chemepedia. 'Exercise: Calculating pressure drop in a packed bed.' https://www.chemepedia.org/wiki/Exercise:_Calculating_pressure_drop_in_a_packed_bed
  5. Ergun, S. (1952). 'Fluid Flow Through Packed Columns.' Chemical Engineering Progress, 48, 89–94.

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *